Thank you for making this thread, Mesk. I just so happened to listen to "The Shattering" last night on a Youtube video upload. I spent the next half hour going back and listening to the previous expansions music to make an analysis of this theme.
So far, I am neutral about the new expansion's music. The Burning Crusade had an excellent, memorable theme. I can still hum the theme of the cinematic closing in on the Dark Portlal in my head. The Sin'dorei and High Elf music accompanied by a rich array of instruments (the cello being the most memorable) made the soundtrack to the Burning Crusade even better.
Wrath of the Lich King expanded on one of my favorite pieces of Blizzard music that came out of WarCraft III. Arthas' theme was so well put together with the child falsetto. The theme is tragic, dark, and fit the mood of one of the canon's most important villains. There are also other enjoying tracks to the soundtrack, including the violin solo of Grizzy Hills that you messaged me about when I was trying to place the music to one of your videos.
Essentially, both Illidan and Arthas had great themes to their expansion's soundtracks.
My issue with Cataclysm is that the series of pieces in the login music does not illustrate a clear theme for the expansion or Deathwing. There are some interesting melodies, including a couple that expand on some of the vanilla tracks which adds a nice nostalgic touch to an expansion that focuses on the original vanilla world.
Some pluses to this theme is the instrumentation continually improves. Russell Brower continues to enrich the music he composes with more versatility and unique sounds from choirs, violins, and horn instruments. Unfortunately, we may not have heard a Deathwing theme yet. I am curious to see what piece Brower will compose when Deathwing is introduced in the opening cinematic. Here is a Youtube clip for those who want to skip on downloading it.
[youtube]
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N-bVd9t2XA0[/youtube]
A Youtuber did his best to breakdown each melody here:
0:00-0:40 is Legends of Azeroth Tempo 0:40-1:31 new stuff 1:31-2:40 Legends of Azeroth 2:40-3:22 Stormwind Cathedral Theme 3:22-4:47 Cold Mountain theme ( Dun Morogh perhaps ) 4:47-5:27 New Moonglade Theme 5:27-6:00 Goblin Theme 6:00-6:40 Continuation of Legends of Azeroth 6:40-7:38 Invincible 7:38-8:36 Eye of the Vortex Theme used in shattered areas 8:37-9:28 Worgen Theme 9:29-10:04 Lootship 10:05-10:57 Ulduar 10:58-12:06 Vanilla Login Some of this confirmed by Dominika's videos
Any thoughts to any particular pieces you guys liked?