Mafia VIII - Chaotic Nights (No longer joinable) - Morning

[Thalraxal]

Oh, the vote is over. lol, missed my chance to vote to lynch Mucky.

It's not too late, Shadowflare!  You can still vote to lynch Mucky and pretend your vote mattered. 

[Ricky_Honejasi]

Shadowflare was walking around at night and the obvious happens ...

This time, the murderer has one heck of a chainsaw and completely cuts Shadowflare's right arm in a flash and blood flew a lot.

Shadowflare desperately tried to run away but got slashed again on the torso. She wasn't cut in half but it's clear she will lose too much blood in such a short time. Death was certain at this point.

Meanwhile, as if it wasn't enough ... ANOTHER murderer comes out of nowhere and shoot her with oil and light her up. She madly runs in circle in an extremely desperate attempt to extinct herself but she was out of strength already.

Shadowflare now falls down on the ground ... body still on fire and blood spilling everywhere on the ground.

Wait a second ...

Shadowflare's body strangely changes into ... CDLVII!

EDIT : It was CDLVII all along!

CDLVII died in the place of Shadowflare's as BOTH murderers had their eyes on Shadowflare.

***MORNING IN***

Game Admin :
Ricky_Honejasi

Players :
Aekenon
AA7Dragoon
Lavarinth
Shadowflare (night targeted on second night but CDLVII died instead of her)
Milldawg
Thalraxal

Killed :
RCCola (lynched on first day)
Tipereth (killed on first night)
Mucky (lynched on second day)
CDLVII (killed on second night by "mistake", escaped death on first night)

[Lavarinth]

... What..?

[Ricky_Honejasi]

... What..?

Shadowflare was aimed by two murderers but CDLVII died instead of her since he was already morphed into Shadowflare's apparence thus the murderers thought it was her until CDLVII morphed back after being killed.

[Thalraxal]

Oh, wow.  The morphlings powers are pretty cool.  Well... were, anyway.  Alas, poor CDLVII.

[ShadowFlare]

Hmm, so who would have made me their target?  I wonder if someone found out my role?

btw, on that note, can I ask what the detectives do?  Like do they find out someone's role and what it does?

[Lavarinth]

At least we can all agree you're innocent. But yeah, CDLVII's role was cool.. Until it backfired. Harshly.

[Milldawg]

I think part of the game is not knowing what the roles do. So I don't think you can ask what detectives do

Anyway, strange emanations tonight. Where last night there were two evil detectives, this night there is only one - perhaps Mucky was one, or perhaps one of them has multiple parts to their role and chose to do something else at night instead. Also, the one good detective did not detect anyone last night - either he's dead or he used another part of his ability instead.

At night, someone also resurrected a person to vote during the next day. So there's a witch role. It's possible the witch role is part of another role, so we can't say for sure that it's a separate role, but SOMEONE dead is gonna have an extra vote today. Ricky probably should have made a note for dead people not to talk if he was gonna do that, but OH WELL.

Aside from these new developments, the night actions were the same as last night. Someone was protected, someone morphed (CDLVII obviously), two people murdered, and one person did nothing (probably has a day role like Judge or something).

So with only six of us left, that leaves the good guys in short supply. Ig Mucky was one of the evil detectives, then there's probably one solo murderer and one murderer-detective team, plus me and a judge, which leaves one person as witch+good detective, which seems like a weird combination. If there's a role that can choose whether to resurrect or detect, that person would be retarded to choose resurrect tonight. It's possible, though, that the witch is evil, which would be stupid and overpowered, but I wouldn't put it past Ricky. In any case, we don't have much to go on.

However, Shadowflare is likely innocent since she was targeted twice. I'm not entirely convinced she wouldn't try to commit suicide just for lols, but it's unlikely enough that it can be ruled it. In any case, if she is evil and trying to commit suicide, we can just let her do it. She'll succeed eventually

So I don't think we should lynch Shadowflare, or me of course. That leaves Lav, Thal, AA7, and Aekenon. Of them, it's very likely that at least two are evil.

So, what do YOU GUYS think?

[Lavarinth]

Of the four of us, one of us is innocent, three of us are not. The only issue is God knows when I try to defend myself I trip on my words and stutter myself to being lynched, haha.

[Ricky_Honejasi]

Hmm, so who would have made me their target?  I wonder if someone found out my role?

btw, on that note, can I ask what the detectives do?  Like do they find out someone's role and what it does?

By MY usual rules (not Milldawg's when he is the game's admin), STANDARD detective can know a person's role.

However, if there is anything more than that, that I cannot tell you.

[Aekenon]

Of the four of us, one of us is innocent, three of us are not. The only issue is God knows when I try to defend myself I trip on my words and stutter myself to being lynched, haha.

Ah, so if you say or do anything suspicious, we should just disregard it.  Understood!


Anyway, if what Milldawg says is true (not that he'd lie... I think), then Mucky probably was an evil detective.  Yesterday, I think there were three people who didn't vote for him... one was CDL, who we already knew was innocent, and the other two were Shadowflare and Lavarinth.  I think it's safe to assume that Shadowflare is innocent, so... that leaves Lavarinth.

If we're to believe that Mucky's partner wouldn't have voted for him, then Lavarinth is our man.  Of course, even Mucky voted Mucky... so maybe this line of thinking doesn't work.  Still, I think it's odd that Lavarinth's final vote yesterday was for Milldawg of all people.

[Milldawg]

No, Lavarinth voted me because I voted for him - not surprising at all. I also don't think we should be so quick to assume Mucky was an evil detective. It may be likely, but we don't know enough about the roles to make that conclusion. For all I know, one person has like twelve roles and everyone else is a villager.

Thal, AA7, what are your thoughts?

[Aekenon]

Lavarinth understood that you were probably innocent though (he said as much), and posted a couple times afterward but didn't change his vote (even after you went and changed your vote yet again).  His initial reaction is understandable, but I guess I just don't get why you'd leave your vote on someone who you claim to know is innocent.

Lav just being Lav?  Hmmm.

[Milldawg]

Oh wait, Ricky can do night actions too. I find it very likely that Ricky is the one who resurrected someone.

That said, we have a few more leads. That makes it very likely that Mucky and Tipereth were detectives of some sort - one good, one evil. I would bet that tipereth was the good one and Mucky was the evil one, because if Mucky were the good detective, there's a very good chance he would have found out something useful to share, and that he would have cared slightly more about the game.

Unfortunately this only tells us about the past, and not about the present, which is of course of more immediate concern.

[Ricky_Honejasi]

For all I know, one person has like twelve roles and everyone else is a villager.

Wrong. All player roles were given either more potential directly or indirectly with a relative balance. The only exception is mine and even then, I can only do ONE night action even if I got access to full array of potential night actions.

As I said before, nobody starts the game as a villager, everyone has some role ... even any sudden new player will get a role.