Campaign Creations

Aekenon wrote: Since when has Negi been considered a possible Observer?  I guess I missed that one.

Oh, Negi claimed to be an Observer at the top of this page, right after Shadowflare did, actually.  Of course, he could have been lying, but being one of the few confirmed innocents right now, I don't see much benefit in him doing that.

EDIT: Ironically, I start a new page.  Negi claimed to be an Observer at the top of the last page.

Negi wrote: Ok, here's what I think is going on:

Observer:
Mucky

Zealot:
Negi
Aekenon

Doctor:
Thalraxal

Obviously evil:
Shadowflare

Shadowflare is obviously evil cause she was just like
I'm an observer mothafuckas

Which is retarded.

EDIT2: Rereading his post, I realize that he might have said: "Shadowflare is obviously evil cause she was just like: "I'm an observer mothafuckas", while I read it as "Shadowflare is obviously evil cause she was just like.  I'm an observer mothafuckas."  Negi?  Did I just totally misinterpret what you said?

Maybe, maybe not.  But that's not important.  This is: Thal, I think you really are a Doctor like he said, which is why you were inclined to take Negi's post as saying he's an Observer.  If he was wrong about you, I don't think you would've taken his post that way.

But I'd like to hear it from your mouth.  Are you indeed the Doctor, perhaps even the one who's been saving me?  Now's not the time to be afraid.  If we know you're the Doctor, then our suspect list is down yet again!  And victory will be close!

Why would an Arbiter save anybody but themselves the first round?

One who is truly noble and selfless would have no problem doing such a thing.  And seeing as how I lived the first round, there's no denying that somebody did just that.

Again, Thalraxal, if you're the Doctor who saved me, saying so now would significantly help to assure victory, not to mention save you from a possible lynching.

I can't take credit for saving you, Aek.  I'm nothing more then a humble Zealot.  Like I said, I knew some of Negi's list was based on theorizing and that's one of the reasons why.

I admit, I would have rather kept my role a secret.  With my name on Negi's list as a Doctor, the Dark Templar may have attacked me instead of a real Arbiter, and I would have happily traded my life to preserve the Arbiters.

The many faces of Thalraxal:

@Negi: Thanks for the vote of confidence, Negi!  I don't want to confirm or deny your claims that I'm an arbiter for obvious reasons though.

AA7: How do we know that you're not a Dark Templar trying to get us to lynch ourselves?   Also, you're curiously absent from Negi's list.

I was just noting that AA7 was one of the few people still alive that is missing from Negi's list.  Of course, Negi's only had the chance to investigate three people, so some of that list has to be based off his own theorizing.
Of course, if one of our Observers has investigated AA7 or myself, or does knows who our last two Dark Templar are, now would be a good time to tell us so we can avoid lynching potentially innocent Protoss.

I can't take credit for saving you, Aek.  I'm nothing more then a humble Zealot.

Dark Templar, give yourself up.  I find it amusing you would take Negi's list seriously, as the foolish templar knows nothing of what he speaks of.  Here in Eridune, much of what he says is widely disregarded.  It is clear you are not from this sector.  And your role is inconsistent.  At first you claim to hint you are an Arbiter, then you admit to Aekenon you are "nothing more than a humble Zealot" while trying to raise doubt of who I am.  I have never had to defend or provide ambiguous clues as to who I am, Thalraxal.  My dedication and passion should reveal whose side I am on.  You, however, have failed in that respect.  In the words of Judicator Aldaris, "Not only have you damned yourself, but you have damned those who have followed you."

AA7Dragoon wrote: In the words of Judicator Aldaris, "Not only have you damned yourself, but you have damned those who have followed you."

Don't put words in my mouth.

First vote first serve: help me lynch Ricky and you'll have my vote at your disposal next round.

People.
I believe Thalraxal is telling us the truth.  If he was a dark templar, would he not claim to be the arbiter as an easy out?  However, Shadowflare is clearly a dark templar. 

ShadowFlare's story is the weakest one at the moment, I agree.  She wildly claimed to be an Observer, yet neglected to mention what her third investigation uncovered.  And the two investigations she did mention were worthless.  It's possible that she just has poor luck, but that kind of story is also one that's all-too-easily crafted by a liar. 

I'd still like to hear what she has to say about the third night.

@AA7: Right now, it looks like your dedication and passion are focused on murdering innocent Protoss in broad daylight.  While your goals of destroying the Dark Templar are admirable, I assure you they're focused in the wrong direction.  If you are innocent as you claim, then we should be working together, not against each other.  Of course, there's no point in me trying to convince you of your error this day, you've already cast your vote and you cannot change that.

Of course, you still haven't answered my question, AA7: What is your role here?  If you are innocent, you have nothing to fear.  I'll know that you're innocent, and turn my attention to finding the real Dark Templar.  I understand if you wish to remain unknown, I didn't want to reveal myself earlier either, but unfortunatly now is not the time for secrets.

@Negi: Thanks for you continued vote of confidence!

I didn't want to force a time limit here, but I'm probably going to have to do so for the next game. I realize these discussions are SUPER IMPORTANT as well as TOTALLY AWESOME, but y'all need to VOTE ALREADY.

ShadowFlare, if you have some sort of insight to share with us, now is the time.

You know, AA7, ShadowFlare aside, if you're just a zealot then you don't really know if anyone is anything yet you've been throwing out names and lynching like God told you.

I find that quite interesting, if you know what I mean, and I think you do.