Page 10 of 15

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Thu May 06, 2010 10:46 pm
by Murdermasterx

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Thu May 06, 2010 10:49 pm
by mAc Chaos
lol, I like how you logged into the forum JUST to get that smiley.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Thu May 06, 2010 11:04 pm
by AA7Dragoon
Well that was a bad combination of misreading posts.  Thanks Krazy, and sorry Murdermasterx.  I didn't see your reveal on page 7, and I badly misread the lists on page 8.  I take back that earlier statement.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 7:42 am
by Murdermasterx
no one is doing anything is there a timer?

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 8:14 am
by Thalraxal
@MurderOopyX: No timer.

This day is dragging on, and I think we've over-analyzed everything we possibly can.  We've got four options:

1- No Lynch - We go for No Lynch and call it a day.  Everyone walks away happy and alive (until the hellspawn do their thing tonight)

2- Lynch AA7

3- Lynch MurderMasterX

4- Lynch Lavarinth

I think I'm leaning towards No Lynch right now.  We've reached the end of what we can discuss today, and I don't think anyone (besides Lav) is confident enough to field a vote against someone.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 10:26 am
by Milldawg
I suppose a no lynch would be all right. We should decide who does what for night actions though. That way, if anyone does something different from what they said, we can catch them easily. As I said before, I intend to decrepify Murdermaster, since I still think he's the most likely to have killed Dread. But "most likely" only by a small margin, since AA7 is still a suspect, and it's possible someone lied about their roles.

I'm not sure what to think about AA7. I'm tempted to suggest Krazy decrepify him, just in case, but if he really is a Paladin, we'd just be shooting ourselves in the foot.

AA7> Your logic is a tad flawed. First of all, Dread isn't that new of a player. Second, you said "This is a principle I've held for 3-4 games by now.  Every time I've had to defend myself on this, and every time I'm innocent in the end." But this is a fallacy. Just because you say it doesn't prove you're innocent. What if you were guilty? You could still insist on it, but that wouldn't make you innocent. This is why I'm not prepared to let you off the hook just yet.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 10:27 am
by Murdermasterx
i see no reason to lynch aa7 and lav's behavior is ridiculous and needs more explanation, i really have no idea what he was trying to say in his explanation post.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 11:54 am
by mAc Chaos
Murdermasterx wrote: no one is doing anything is there a timer?
Well, you can't wait for everyone else to do something.  Each person has to do their own part to move things along.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 12:13 pm
by Krazy
I will decrepify murdermaster, since I don't think losing a barbarian's bash is that big of a deal.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 12:40 pm
by Thalraxal
I'm not sure how I feel about everyone revealing their night actions.  Still... STRATEGY!

AA7 shouldn't reveal his target, since that would make his ability somewhat useless.  However, it might be worthwhile having an Amazon observe his actions.  I agree that decrepifying MurderMasterX is a good idea.  Sorry, Oopy, but your ability is kinda annoying and you are the most logical suspect.

I'm still undecided who I want to investigate tonight.  Lav, any thoughts on the subject?  We probably should coordinate here.

I have to admit, I feel quite giddy.  You've all willingly surrendered your only defence against my powers, granting me access to all your secrets.  Haha.  Hahaha.

MUAWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 12:49 pm
by Lavarinth
Thalraxal wrote: I'm not sure how I feel about everyone revealing their night actions.  Still... STRATEGY!

AA7 shouldn't reveal his target, since that would make his ability somewhat useless.  However, it might be worthwhile having an Amazon observe his actions.  I agree that decrepifying MurderMasterX is a good idea.  Sorry, Oopy, but your ability is kinda annoying and you are the most logical suspect.

I'm still undecided who I want to investigate tonight.  Lav, any thoughts on the subject?  We probably should coordinate here.

I have to admit, I feel quite giddy.  You've all willingly surrendered your only defence against my powers, granting me access to all your secrets.  Haha.  Hahaha.

MUAWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!
Though revealing roles does put the entire cast at stake to know who to target, it guarantees us a successful investigation overnight. Obviously, my initial target would AA7. This shouldn't be an issue if I'm protected, isn't that right, AA7?

Though, I'm up for discussion, Thal.

If you guys prefer to not lynch anything, so be it, but don't think I'm just crying wolf.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 12:52 pm
by AA7Dragoon
Do not decrepify me. I have a target in mind. If I'm not killed, the night's events could prove useful. I am up for a No Lynch vote. We'll know a lot more now that the roles have been revealed.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 12:58 pm
by AA7Dragoon
I won't say who Lavarinth, but yes, someone can count on protection tonight. Feel free to investigate me.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 1:30 pm
by Milldawg
Krazy> Did you miss my post saying I'll decrep MMX, or did you just want to do the honors yourself? Or have us both do it?

Yeah, I guess it doesn't make sense for ALL of us to announce our actions. But some coordinate could help.

Re: MAFIA: Sanctuary - DAY One

Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 1:42 pm
by Thalraxal
@Lav: Alright, I'll let you handle AA7.

@Milldawg, Krazy: Double Decrepify!  It's the only way to be sure!