Campaign Creations

CDLVII wrote: Funny thing is... if we were to reveal that one position, knowing that his life required protection. Would the Dark Templars assume that he was shielded constantly and continue butchering our brothers? We could say they'll assume that the position is under protection, leaving us with 2 completely free cloaks.

Of course, there's always the risk that if an important role is known to us, they may become the target of the Dark Templars' disruption instead of being killed, thus being unable to gather additional information that night anyway.  So revealing an important role is still kind of a double-edged sword.

The other side of this is that staying silent can also be a risk, as someone may die without ever getting to tell anyone the information they gathered and without having a chance to be protected.

Just adding my own opinions on the pros and cons of revealing (or not revealing) roles in general.  My opinion is also that with the number of people still remaining it is probably too early for the benefit of knowing who is innocent to outweigh the drawback of the Dark Templar knowing who has certain special roles.  However, knowing someone is guilty possibly does outweigh that drawback.  It is still a risk, though, because the Arbiters could be dead already or if someone plans to have the HT confirm their role, there is the risk that the HT could be dead, and thus unable to confirm it.

If the Praetor is still alive, only he knows whether we even have anyone left to depend on, or if our waiting would only be in vain.


EDIT:
Is there someone who keeps replying and deleting the message?  I keep getting e-mail notifications without seeing any reply to anything. lol

the only people who have done anything at all to raise any suspicion are lav and mac, and neither have done enough to warrant a lynching, but at the same time with 2 people going per night every night we dont lynch someone is a serious setback. we could have 0 observers left at this point, maybe it's too early to start lynching without hard evidence, but 1-2 more rounds like this and we wont have much of a choice. its safe to assume our observers have found nothing and its not unreasonable to assume that at least one is dead, maybe both.

if we dont lynch someone today, and we dont get any evidence tomorrow, it leaves us with no choice really and we pretty much have to start killing people rather or not we have hard evidence.

if we were to kill someone today id probably pick lav, though if more people suspected mac id go with that too. either way, we have to consider it if nothing comes up.

Has DoW spoken at all yet?

I don't think Taer has either.

Aekenon wrote: Has DoW spoken at all yet?

DoW's spoken, he voted for "No Lynch" on Day 1.

Quiet people, speak up!

Well, for now I'm just going to go with no vote and let everyone else decide, because with this little information I still have no idea what to do.  I'm not putting it in bold, though, in case something is brought up and my vote is needed.

mAc Chaos wrote: Unless I'm mistaken, there are only two Observers.

Huhm I kept saying four? lol wishful thinking.

There are Four Dark Templars. and Two Observers. That actually puts a real constraint on how long it will be until just ONE observer has at least dispelled a sizable amount of suspects.

Also Abstain.

I got crucified for abstaining second round last time.

Mainly by the Dark Templar.  Also, you didn't die in vain. (lol)

Remember guys, 'Abstain' means you choose not to vote.  'No lynch' means you vote for no one to be lynched.  Or, we can all abstain and let Lav get away with killing mAc with a single vote.

Almost sounds acceptable.

tipereth wrote: I don't think Taer has either.

lol think again

Oh yeah... I forgot about Lav lynching me.  lool.

We have until 1 AM tonight right?

Lavarinth has voted to lynch mAc without evidence or even a rational explanation. However, he did so very quickly after the day broke, leading me to believe that he is not a Dark Templar, but instead just a dick. I vote NO LYNCH.

I don't like this.  We're handing the Dark Templar another two lives, but...

I'm not convinced that either Lav or mAc are guilty at this point and I've got no other suspects.  I'm kinda paranoid that one or more of our quiet people are Dark Templar and just want to watch us kill each other...

I feel that voting for no lynch would be the best option right now... but...  Ah, hell.  I've got a theory and I'm going with it.

I vote to lynch Lav