Mafia VIII - Chaotic Nights (No longer joinable) - Morning

[ShadowFlare]

Yeah, I'm not changing.  Even if there are two mafia teams, not killing Lavarinth now would be a mistake, because that may mean he gets to kill another tomorrow, just like he did to Thalraxal (and of course he would use it, since he already revealed it).  If Lavarinth is indeed alone, it would be beneficial to everyone if he was lynched.

[Aekenon]

Okay, wow... a lot happened since earlier.  Glad I came back.

I vote to lynch Lavarinth, for obvious reasons!

[Milldawg]

Thank you! Come again!

[AA7Dragoon]

I leave for two hours and come back to all this!?  I knew Lavarinth was Mafia but wow, what an ability.  This means if there are two Mafia teams after all, they're killing each other.  Because Lavarinth just killed Thal.

Kill Lavarinth.

[Ricky_Honejasi]

Thus Lavarinth was horribly killed for the crime of killing Thalraxal.

The people is filled with great joy that a true murderer was put to cold justice.

Meanwhile DrumsofWar is arriving closer and closer to town by car.

***NIGHT FALLS***

Game Admin :
Ricky_Honejasi

Players :
Aekenon
AA7Dragoon
Shadowflare (night targeted on second night but CDLVII died instead of her)
Milldawg

Players to arrive next morning :
DrumsofWar

Killed :
RCCola (lynched on first day)
Tipereth (killed on first night)
Mucky (lynched on second day)
CDLVII (killed on second night by "mistake", escaped death on first night)
Thalraxal (killed by third day by special action of Lavarinth's)
Lavarinth (lynched on third day, revealed as FANATIC MAFIOSO)

[Ricky_Honejasi]

During the night ...

Milldawg was out as usual and then a black car drove at 200 km/hour over him, killing him ...

Somehow Milldawg's eyes shines and then his body miraculously go up by magic and his body was restored!!!

Milldawg was killed but came back to life by himself. However, it's clear that by his fatigue that he won't be able to do the same exploit twice in the same month!

AA7Dragoon quietly took a glass of wine bracing the moon's light. However, some truck with dynamite crashed into his house and exploded him to little bits.

AA7Dragoon was killed at his house!

***MORNING***

DrumsofWar arrives in town as a brand new immigrant in town!

Game Admin :
Ricky_Honejasi

Players :
Aekenon
Shadowflare (night targeted on second night but CDLVII died instead of her)
Milldawg (killed once, still alive until second "true death")
DrumsofWar (Immigrant)

Killed :
RCCola (lynched on first day)
Tipereth (killed on first night)
Mucky (lynched on second day)
CDLVII (killed on second night by "mistake", escaped death on first night)
Thalraxal (killed by third day by special action of Lavarinth's)
Lavarinth (lynched on third day, revealed as FANATIC MAFIOSO)
AA7Dragoon (killed on third night)

[ShadowFlare]

lol, still two targets?  I wonder if one of those was done by Ricky...

[DrumsofWar]

Why hello there, guys.  Nice...town you have here.

I'm...going to go munch on Lav's torso or something. 

[Aekenon]

Wait a minute...  no matter how you look at it, isn't that impossible?  Lav was obviously one of the killers, yet there were still two deaths last night, one of them being AA7, whom I thought was also a mafioso (and maybe he was?).

I'm so very confused.  There's something weird at work here.

[Milldawg]

Told you I was invincible.

But not any more. SHIT.

Anyway, no one got resurrected today so it's up to us. Assuming ShadowFlare is innocent, that means AA7 and Aek were both killers. Thus Aekenon targeted AA7 and AA7 targeted me. That, or as Aekenon says, Ricky killed one of them. In any case, the odds are very high that Aekenon is a killer. vote Aekenon

[Aekenon]

Okay, so... at first, I was incredibly puzzled, but there's really only one solution here.

There were two kills.  One of them probably came from AA7, but what about the second one?  There's five suspects.

DoW - He just emerged, so he couldn't have been able to use his power yet, if he even has one.  It couldn't be him.

Aekenon - Well, I know I'm innocent.

ShadowFlare - Was shot.  Twice.  It surely isn't her.

Milldawg - I declared him innocent early on.  ...wait a minute, why did I do that again?

Ricky - The game ends when all the mafia are dead, right?  Then the second shot couldn't have come from Ricky... and I doubt he would so directly impact the game with an action like that anyway.

Now that we're in this situation, I can't help but think that me considering Milldawg innocent was pre-mature.  It was at an early stage in the game, so I guess I was happy to take his word for it and cross his name off the list, but... really, what does that list of his actually prove?  Nothing... at least, there's no way for me to verify if everything he said was true.  Or, even if he could produce such a list, does that mean he's innocent?  I thought so at first, but... I believe I was mistaken.  Now I'm thinking it was all a clever ruse, so that he'd earn our trust.

Plus... As we've seen, Milldawg has the ability to live through a mafia hit.  Isn't that ability a little powerful for an innocent to have?  Yeah.  But then I remembered... there's apparently multiple mafia teams warring against one another.  What if that ability was given to certain members of the mafia so that they would be more resistant to hits from rival teams?  Makes more sense to me.

In this case, I'm thinking... AA7 shot at Milldawg, and Milldawg shot at AA7.  But AA7 didn't have the ability to survive.  Maybe AA7's partner who did have that ability was lynched (assuming anyone besides Milldawg even had such an ability).

I vote for Milldawg, because the remaining Mafioso can't be anyone but him!

[ShadowFlare]

lol, I suppose I'll just go ahead and vote Aekenon for now.

[Aekenon]

Then he kills you (or DoW) at night, and... well, then I guess it's a tie.  Which usually means a mafia victory.

Looking back through the thread now, Milldawg's behavior seems a lot more devious.  If only I had thought of this sooner... he's been pulling our strings all along!

[DrumsofWar]

He does have +10 to his Puppetmaster skill since he's GM'ed most previous games!

[Ricky_Honejasi]

Ricky - The game ends when all the mafia are dead, right?

The golden rule for a game with special unknown roles is the following :
There will be only an auto-end with each person's most favored outcome when there is only ONE logical choice (from the player's point of view) from all sides involved in their survival (usually when it's down to two or sometimes three persons).

Example :  If there is only one non-revealed mafioso vs one innocent at daytime, it would auto-cause a tie lynch vs each other with 1 vote worth (thus no dead) and then the mafioso auto-kill the innocent at night thus going into victory in that mafioso's favor.

Also, if there is somehow multiple mafia teams, there must be only one surviving mafia team for that team to claim victory. Thus even if there are only two mafia teams remaining and no innocent left, those teams continue the game with mornings as if there was still an innocent.